Bailey's 2025 Top Selling Premium Cigars 5,4,3,2

Gary Cruice
3 days ago
2 min read

We started our Top Ten Countdown last week and now cover the next four best selling premium cigars from last year! These are a mix of premium cigars new to the countdown and repeaters.

5 - Aganorsa JFR

These have been a shop favorite almost since we opened! 2025 saw the addition of the 20th Anniversary Maduro (almost all gone). We carry the Connecticut and Maduro Robusto and Titan. We also carry the JFR XT Corojo and Maduro 6x60. We'll be adding the JFR Jr Corojo and Maduro. You should try all of them!

4 - AJ Fernandez New World Oscuro

Always rated highly - CA 92, Cigar Snob 92, Cigar Journal 94. A Nicaraguan Puro with tobaccos from Condega, Esteli, Jalapa, and Ometepe. Medium-to-full bodied, while simultaneously rich and smooth. We also carry the New World Cameroon, Connecticut, Dorado, and Puro Especial. Go ahead, expand discover more of the New World!

3 - Bailey's Shop Cigar

We're delighted that our premium cigar project has been so well received! This took over a year and was the result of many folks. Alfonso Reinoso of Artista presented Jaime and Gary with the first samples. They then brought in Brody and continued working with Alfonso Reinoso and his team at Artista to develop the final blend - the one you like so much! San Andres Wrapper, Cameroon Binder from Africa, and a proprietary blend of fillers!

2 - Punch Knuckle Buster

No stranger to our Best Seller lists, the Knuckle Buster comes in three different wrappers - Habano, Maduro, Shade. We carry each in the 6x60 Gordo size. A combination of price, construction, and flavor have found the Knuckle Buster a home in our humidor!

Check in next week for our best selling premium cigar from 2025 and a review of past lists.

This is the last week to get in on our LFD Humidor Raffle. Also, Saturday the 31st is the Carencro Parade. Bailey's will close at 3PM that day.