Bailey's Shop Favorite Premium Cigar

Time to reveal Bailey's best selling premium cigar of 2026! JC Newman's Trader Jack's Original Toro! We sold more of this spiced baby than any other premium cigar last year!

Today, J.C. Newman is the last working cigar factory in Cigar City, USA. Different from other factories, their machine-assisted cigars are manned by skilled cigar makers. Many of the dedicated cigar makers have been with J.C. Newman for twenty years or more, perfecting their craft and making the most flavorful value cigars on the market.

Trader Jack’s cigars offer the same quality construction and flavor as all Tampa-made cigars but with a Caribbean twist. Each cigar is spiked with a little aromatic island spice before it’s packed away. The final touch adds a unique taste to the cigar that has the ability to transport anyone to a Caribbean state of mind.

This is the first time that Drew Estate's Isla del Sol is not on our list! This is probably due to the increasing popularity of the Deadwood line and our addition of Trader Jack's. Our Fugly sales have also dropped a bit, but Artista's Paper Boy is steadily growing in popularity. We carry a wide variety of sweet/flavored cigars, plenty of small cigars, and all kinds of inexpensive cigars (singles and bundles). Stop in, look around, and try something new today! We'll be waiting.